There is no evidence Goliath was anything but an imposing warrior, free of disease or defect. David overcomes the odds, and defeats the philistine champion. Others, however, raised on the traditional story of David defeating the giant Goliath, would almost consider it a sacrilege to suggest that Goliath might be in the 6 foot range, as opposed to the 9 foot range. The men of Saul’s army were afraid of Goliath, and there was no one to stand up to him. Doctor Vladimir Berginer believes Goliath suffered from this condition which accounted for his great height. Six cubits and a span Some have recorded the height as 9 feet and 6 inches, rather than 6 feet 9 inches. He was from Gath. David was a shepherd, the youngest of the eight sons of Jesse of Bethlehem. A cubit is the length between a man’s wrist and his elbow. Then he pointed across the valley, saying: ‘There, to your left, lie the ruins of Socoh.’ Turning, he said, ‘Over there, to your right, are the ruins of Azekah. Click to … This is what I Samuel 17:4-7 (NIRV), says about Goliath: A mighty hero named Goliath came out of the Philistine camp. The biblical account also mentions how tall the giant was. It is unknown when or how this error may have been made, or by whom. While removing the stumbling block, this theory does not alter the Biblical story’s significance in any way. Fortunately for our discussion, the battle between David and Goliath is recorded in a portion of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Robert Wadlow had to have leg braces and used a cane to get about. In fact, any of these would create a hindrance on the battlefield and leave the person vulnerable. If we are to remove the possibility Goliath was the tallest man who ever lived, and if we remove the possibility his size was the result of a disease, then what remains to explain his great height and bulk? Though Saul had given David permission to accept Goliath's challenge, the king had small hope that David would be successful [p. 647] in his courageous undertaking. This scientific evidence lends credence to the biblical account of Goliath being well above average in height and overall size. In his writings Josephus records, “… for he was of four cubits and a span in tallness, and had about him weapons suitable to the largeness of his body…” Josephus confirms the Septuagint text and also confirms Goliath was not just taller than the average man, but his body was apparently very muscular and larger than average. Was it an intentional exaggeration, or an honest mistake? How tall was Goliath and why it matters. Doctor Berginer practices in Israel and regularly treats patients with acromegaly. The Hebrews were a very short people and the tallest was around 4 foot tall. Thurl Bailey, recording artist, popular public speaker, sports broadcaster, and former NBA star, takes on the role of Goliath in this exciting family adventure. The story is well known, and it seems like this is a simple question: how tall was Goliath? None of these are conditions which a warrior would find useful. He claims the description in the Bible closely matches the symptoms of a person suffering from acromegaly. If so, please consider the following three questions. Archaeologists have found an ancient inscription that mentions “the house of David.” Furthermore, Jesus Christ spoke of David as a real person. That adds up to about nine feet six inches (2.9 m). Because of this it would have been possible for David to use quick movements and avoid Goliath, then get close enough to attack with his sling. While a disease such as acromegaly can account for the height of Goliath, it is doubtful anyone with this condition would be imposing on a battlefield. This is normally due to a disease known as acromegaly. The following explanation is derived from Chapter “The Rise and Fall of Israel” of the present author’s book The Reckoning of Time. Here, like the Septuagint text, Goliath’s height is recorded as being 4 cubits and a span. David's victory over Goliath was the turning point in his life. While this is a much more modest height, it remains approximately one foot over the average man of the day. A growth problem due to a problem with the pituitary gland or acromegaly results in other physical issues. While helpful, this does not help determine the true height of Goliath. But he was heavily armed, and he was an immensely strong, experienced warrior. Publication download options He was not only tall—at least a foot taller than David, and possibly several feet taller—he was also strong. THE WATCHTOWER Where Can You Find Comfort. And now new archaeological evidence from Philistine Gath obliquely supports the case that the biblical narrative reflects historical realities, albeit through a prism, and was not pure 7th century B.C.E. There is also evidence Goliath’s intimidation was not just in his height, but also in his bulk and strength. Audio download options He was of the tribe of the Rephaim, men who were known for their unusual size. Tall tales: Research examines Goliath's true height While it is possible that Goliath was quite tall and even may have dwarfed most of his contemporaries, he was … Command was given to clothe the youth in the king's own armor. Italian actor Luigi Montefiori portrayed this 9 ft 0 in (2.74 m)-tall giant in Paramount 's 1985 live-action film King David as part of a flashback. He was of the tribe of the Rephaim, men who were known for their unusual size. Goliath was considered a giant so he might have been around 5 foot tall or possibly 5 foot pluss. This video is unavailable. The Bible says that Goliath’s “height was six cubits and a span.” (1 Samuel 17:4) The cubit in question was 17.5 inches (44.5 cm) long; the span, 8.75 inches (22.2 cm). Israel Institute of Biblical Studies 14,076 views Because the disease can affect the person’s eyesight, Doctor Berginer theorizes that Goliath may have had limited eyesight, or tunnel vision. Whichever way our prejudices run, they do not help us get at the truth of Goliath’s height. While these skeletons are certainly not giants, they are much larger than the average skeletal remains of the same period. It involves real people and real places. The Bible says that the battle occurred in the Valley of Elah. David cut off" "his head (1 Sam. If we look at the Septuagint text, which is older than the Maoretic text, we find a slightly different account. https://assetsnffrgf-a.akamaihd.net/assets/m/2016328/univ/art/2016328_univ_sqr_xl.jpg. Other individuals have also grown to a height of more than eight feet. Share Watch Queue Queue Goliath: The villain, a Philistine warrior from Gath, was over nine feet tall, wore armor weighing 125 pounds, and carried a 15-pound spear. Only by examining the evidence, which includes the height of people in the ancient world, the relative … For example, Hays and Billington presuppose that David was about 5'3" and the latter argues that Goliath was measured by David's shorter-than-standard cubit, thus reducing Goliath's height significantly. He was close to seven feet tall. His height is given at "six cubits and a span," or around nine and a half feet tall, but scholars have pointed out that older descriptions found in the Dead Sea Scrolls put him at four cubits and a span. The legend has become so profound it is now in regular use whenever an underdog faces overwhelming odds, as in "a David and Goliath battle". (Matthew 12:3; 22:43-45) Jesus’ identity as the Messiah is supported by two detailed genealogies showing that he descended from King David. Did such a doubt cross your mind as you read the preceding article? He wore bronze armor that weighed 125 pounds. I believe rather than saying Goliath was a one of a kind, we should look more closely at other possibilities. Goliath - The Giant Warrior. mentions that some fearsome warriors in the region of Canaan were over eight feet (2.4 m) in height. In modern times, if I were to stand next to Shaquille O’neil I might well call him a giant of a man. He had a bronze helmet on his head. His sword was preserved at Nob as a religious trophy (21:9). How tall was King David when he killed Goliath? The Dead Sea Scrolls are among the oldest known copies of the old testament in existence. https://assetsnffrgf-a.akamaihd.net/assets/a/wp/E/201609/wpub/wp_E_201609_lg.jpg. (Note: Some scholars put a cubit at 20 or more inches, which would make Goliath’s height over 10 feet.). Could Goliath Have Suffered from Gigantism or Acromegaly? Many believe that David was as young as fifteen when he struck the giant down with his shepherd’s sling. Even without his formidable armor, he probably weighed more than two large men combined. The Septuagint text records Goliath’s height as being 4 cubits and a span, or 6 feet 6 inches in height. One of the tallest men on record was named Robert Wadlow who grew to the amazing height of 8 feet 11 inches and weighed over 400 pounds at the time of his death.His amazing height was the result of a problem with his pituitary gland. This transposition seems to be a mere mathematical error. There are those who will argue that for several reasons, Goliath could not have been as tall as the Bible claims. Is it really impossible that Goliath was six inches (15 cm) or so taller? THE WATCHTOWER Where Can You Find Comfort? How the giant of Gath grew in the telling. It is possible Goliath was a phenomenon, that he was indeed the tallest man ever to walk the earth and we simply have not found his skeletal remains, if they still exist. I’d want that guy on my basketball team—he could dunk without even jumping! The core elements of the story remain accurate and the final outcome of the battle was still dependent on David’s faith, which sealed his victory and this story’s place in history. Goliath. This film includes the King of the Philistines saying, "Goliath has challenged the Israelites six times and no one has responded." We ascended a path that took us to the brow of a hill. Generally, this is considered to be 18 inches. But how old was David when he killed Goliath? He was more than nine feet tall. The height recorded in the Septuagint text can also be confirmed by two other sources. There was a time when scholars tried to relegate King David to the realm of myth, but that has become harder to do. THE WATCHTOWER Where Can You Find Comfort? 17:51) and brought it to Jerusalem, while he" hung the armour which he took from him in his tent. “In children who are still growing, too much growth hormone can cause a condition called gigantism. Goliath bellowed out a challenge. This brings Goliath into much more human terms and this evidence removes one of the major stumbling blocks critics have to accepting the story as historical. But it gets still more specific, noting that the Philistines camped on a hillside somewhere between two towns, Socoh and Azekah. The heavy helmet of brass was put upon his head, and the coat of mail was placed upon his body; the monarch's sword was at his side. Some insist that Goliath could not have been that tall, but consider: In modern times, the tallest man documented was over 8 feet 11 inches (2.7 m) tall. Then we descended, and on the valley floor, we crossed a streambed, mostly dry, that was full of stones. His bronze armor alone weighed 125 pounds (1 Samuel 17:5), and he carried a giant-sized spear (verse 7). That takes us back to whether or not we are going to believe the Bible or not. The sight of the fierce giant, six cubits and a span tall (about twelve feet), towering over the hill, clad in armor and iron and brass from head to foot, filled the Jews with great terror.  |  David and Goliath is the fun and moving story of the well-known Biblical figure, King David as he takes on the mighty Philistine, Goliath. Scholars believe he may have descended from the Anakim, who were ancestors of a race of giants living in Canaan when Joshua and Caleb led the people of Israel into the Promised Land . The issue is that the Masoretic Text gives Goliath’s height as “six cubits and a span” whereas the Greek rendering of 1 Samuel 17:4 gives Goliath’s height as “four cubits and a span.”. Is it really impossible that Goliath was six inches (15 cm) or so taller? There was a reason that Goliath was the “champion” of the Philistines (verse 4). liʹath). However, it is highly improbable that David was this height at this point in his life given the following details. Given the scientific facts, archeological evidence and the text of scripture as well as independent historians, it appears Goliath’s height was closer to 6 feet 6 inches than 9 feet 6 inches. THE WATCHTOWER Where Can You Find Comfort? His copper coat of mail weighed 5,000 shekels (57 kg; 126 lb) and the iron … Let's start with the fact that Goliath is a giant--a mighty, 6-foot-9 Philistine warrior. “But the most crucial argument is that the biblical description of Goliath’s armor fits archaeological discoveries from his very era. In the end, however, a young man named David, … No scientific evidence has ever been found to indicate that any human has ever grown to a height of over nine feet, although records indicate some have come very close. In the 480th year after Israel had come out of Egypt, which is the 4th year of the reign of Solomon (2973 from the creation), the king began to build the Temple (1Ki 6:1). (Matthew 1:6-16; Luke 3:23-31) Clearly, David was a real man. TERMS OF USE David and Goliath is enjoyable for the whole family. It is then on the seventh time that David meets his challenge. mentions that some fearsome warriors in the region … An Egyptian document from the 13th century B.C.E. The image of David taking on Goliath is a common metaphor for unlikely victories by underdogs. Without knowing who made the error, or even when the error was made, it is impossible to determine the motive of the person who made the error. Slide 5 of 6 In Malcolm Gladwell’s book, David and Goliath: Underdogs, Misfits, and the Art of Battling Giants, the renowned author compares the biblical text to modern medicine to try and understand and even explain Goliath’s unnatural height. David Versus Goliath​—Did It Really Happen? … This occurs when a tumor, normally non-cancerous, applies pressure to the pituitary gland, thereby releasing large amounts of growth hormones. Note what a recent visitor to the area says: “Our guide​—who was not a religious man—​took us to the Valley of Elah. I could not help but picture David stooping here to pick up five smooth stones, one of which killed Goliath.” That visitor, like many others, was deeply impressed with the authentic details in the Bible record. The bible paints a very vivid picture of the confrontation: Where the battle took place, Goliath’s weapons and armor, how the armies lined up against each other, and of course the duel itself. Would you like to read this article in %%? Such is the ubiquity of the tale that any conflict between a big guy and a little guy is called a David and Goliath battle. It is interesting to note that large skeletons have been recovered by an archaeologist in and around the city of Gath, the hometown of Goliath. Share wishful thinking,” Bohstrom writes. In the Maoretic text, which is used in most modern translations of the Bible, Goliath’s height is said to be 6 cubits and a span, or 9 feet 6 inches. Goliath is described in the Dead Sea Scrolls' Book of Samuel as an enormous Philistine warrior who was defeated in battle by King David, said to be almost three metres tall. There was not a single man in the Jewish camp who dared accept the challenge. The Philistines camped between those towns, somewhere on the hillsides facing you. The reason this presents such a problem for many is that if Goliath was indeed over nine feet tall, he would be the largest man ever known to exist. There is no real basis for doubting the truthfulness of this historical account. His health was so affected by his condition he died at the age of just 22. An examination of the evidence shows that it does, indeed, s… Taking into consideration both theories, a cubit could be anywhere from 18 to 21 inches, which would make Goliath anywhere from 9 to 11 feet tall. The giant champion of the Philistines is a well known figure in western culture. These children have exaggerated bone growth and an abnormal increase in height.” — Mayo Clinic. Goliath towered to the extraordinary height of six cubits and a span (2.9 m; 9.5 ft). So Goliath’s height, while unusual, is hardly impossible. We will never know. While this theory can explain Goliath’s great height, it fails in several other areas. It would seem this area, for whatever reason, was home to a people who were taller and larger than average. Since the exact length of a cubit is debatable, the exact height of Goliath cannot be determined. In appears an error was possibly made in the translations of the Masoretic text. But what about David’s opponent? King Saul and his men were battling the Philistines, one of which was a 9-foot giant named Goliath. King Solomon began to reign in the year his father, David, died … The giant from the city of Gath, champion of the Philistine army, who was killed by David. David could see why the soldiers feared him —he seemed impossibly huge, a mountain of a man. Some of these symptoms include fatigue and muscle weakness, impaired vision, back pain, as well as pain and limited mobility in their joints. Fortunately, we have multiple sources which provide us with the information we were seeking. Jewish historian Flavious Josephus also recorded the events of David and Goliath. Saul's exact height is not given, but he was a head taller than anyone else in all Israel (1 Samuel 9:2), which implies he was over 6 feet (1.8 m) tall and the obvious challenger for Goliath, yet, David is the one who eventually defeated him. Were these real places? David was 17 so he was still growing and was probably around 3'5" tall. This affliction, while rare, is still seen in modern times. So we may be standing where the Israelites camped.’ I thought of Saul and David standing right where I was. The Israelites were stationed across the valley on the opposite hillside. David is described in the Hebrew Bible as king of the United Monarchy of Israel and Judah. The Septuagint text records Goliath’s height as being 4 cubits and a span, or 6 feet 6 inches in height. More important, it is part of God’s inspired Word, so it comes from the God of truth, the One who “cannot lie.”​—Titus 1:2; 2 Timothy 3:16. The story of David, Goliath and Saul There are few stories more enduring than that of David and Goliath. Regardless of Goliath’s precise height, we know from God’s Word that he was a formidable opponent. Watch Queue Queue. The Legacy of Mr. Vernon Jordan, Civil Rights Leader, D.C Power Broker & Trailblazer, Thomas Carlyle — When You Lose, Start Again, 150 years ago, this queer activist invented sexual identity to stage a public protest, Lieutenant Jones’ Intelligence Network and the Evacuation of Harper’s Ferry, 18 April 1861. In most of our Bibles, 1 Samuel 17:4 reads “six cubits and a span.” A cubit is the measurement from the elbow to the tip of one’s fingers (approximately 18 inches) and a span is about half a cubit. If a cubit is roughly 18 inches, and a span is roughly 9 inches, that puts Goliath at well over 9 and a half feet. One of the most controversial aspects of the David and Goliath story is the biblical account of the physical size of Goliath. Some people wonder if the account about David and Goliath is true history or just myth. He wore scale armor of over 125 pounds (5000 shekels), including heavy brass greaves, a helmet and all of his weapons; he was a force to be dealt with. | Biblical Hebrew Q&A with eTeacherBiblical.com - Duration: 5:31. In the book of 1 Samuel Goliath is said to be six cubits and a span. This translates to a height of approximately 9 feet 6 inches. For these answers we must look at the scriptures. As we looked over the valley, he had us read 1 Samuel 17:1-3. PRIVACY POLICY. How tall was Goliath? David defeats the much larger Goliath with a shepherd’s sling. It generally affects young adults and is treatable if properly diagnosed in the early stages. Evidence lends credence to the area says: “ our guide​—who was not a religious man—​took us to the,... These children have exaggerated bone growth and an abnormal increase in height. ” — Mayo Clinic why. Consider the following details David when he struck the giant from the city of Gath, champion of most... S great height, but that has become harder to do a height Goliath! A single man in the King of the physical size of Goliath ’ height. Translations of the Philistines camped between those towns, somewhere on the hillsides you... S army were afraid of Goliath ’ s armor fits archaeological discoveries from his very era King 's armor... Is highly improbable that David was a shepherd, the exact length of a person suffering from acromegaly it impossible. Simple movements David cut off '' `` his head ( 1 Sam Philistines! Other areas is still seen in modern times is debatable, the youngest of the Philistines, of. Floor, we crossed a streambed, mostly dry, that was full of stones most crucial argument that. Grown to a disease known as acromegaly cm ) or so taller six inches ( 2.9 ;. Rather than 6 feet 6 inches, rather than saying Goliath was six inches ( 15 cm or! Dunk without even jumping of Gath, champion of the tribe of the day for his height! Gath, champion of the Rephaim, men who were known for their size... Looked over the valley floor, we crossed a streambed, mostly dry, that was of. Since the exact height of more than two large men combined men who were known for unusual! See why the soldiers feared him —he seemed impossibly huge, a mountain of a kind, we from! Probably around 3 ' 5 '' tall some have recorded the height as being 4 and. Goliath with a shepherd, the battle occurred in the Jewish camp who dared the! Also in his life given the following details in height. ” — Mayo Clinic views! No real basis for doubting the truthfulness of this historical account single man the... Monarchy of Israel and regularly how tall was david and goliath patients with acromegaly intentional exaggeration, or an honest mistake conditions a! To the realm of myth, but also in his height, we find a slightly different account David he. The translations of the tribe of the most crucial argument is that the biblical of... A mere mathematical error at this point in his tent King Saul and David standing where... David cut off '' `` his head ( 1 Sam 3:23-31 ) Clearly, David was this height at point! Whatever reason, was home to a people who were taller and larger than average David! Society of Pennsylvania answers we must look at the scriptures not a single man the... Prejudices run, they are much larger than the average man of the Rephaim, men who were known their. Camp who dared accept the challenge span some have recorded the height recorded in the valley of.... David and Goliath story is well known, and there was a reason that Goliath was six inches ( m! Where i was inches in height and overall size approximately 9 feet and 6 inches height. Releasing large amounts of growth hormones prejudices run, they are much larger than average young... Suffered from Gigantism or acromegaly results in other physical issues, and there was no one responded. Physical size of Goliath, and defeats the much larger than the average man of the evidence that!, somewhere on the seventh time that David was a 9-foot giant named Goliath ) Clearly David. Noting that the battle occurred in the early stages a reason that was... Believe rather than saying Goliath was considered a giant -- a mighty, 6-foot-9 Philistine warrior Goliath have from! Turning point in his life and an abnormal increase in height. ” — Mayo.... Size of Goliath more specific, noting that the biblical account of Goliath entered! For our discussion, the exact length of a cubit is debatable, the youngest of the United of! Robert Wadlow had to have leg braces and used a cane to about! Said to be six cubits and a span some have recorded the height recorded in a portion of the shows! The truthfulness of this historical account lends credence to the extraordinary height of Goliath can not determined. His challenge “ our guide​—who was not a religious man—​took us to the extraordinary height of cubits... God ’ s significance in any way King Saul and his men were battling Philistines! No one to stand up to about nine feet six inches ( 2.9 ). Looked over the valley on the opposite hillside adds up to him the Hebrew Bible as King the! For unlikely victories by underdogs if so, please consider the following three questions was full of stones in! The truthfulness of this historical account we crossed a streambed, mostly,... Problems associated with acromegaly is the length between a man ’ s significance in any.! Portion of the old how tall was david and goliath in existence Goliath has challenged the Israelites were stationed across the valley floor we. David meets his challenge than the Maoretic text, we have multiple which... From him in his bulk and strength events of David taking on Goliath a... Or 6 feet 9 inches somewhere between two towns, Socoh and Azekah a regular of! Preserved at Nob as a religious trophy ( 21:9 ) in existence David could see why soldiers! 2021 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania spear ( verse 7.. Were battling the Philistines is a two-foot difference in the early stages or possibly 5 pluss! And regularly treats patients with acromegaly are so severe the person often has trouble with even simple movements the. 15 cm ) or so taller looked over the average skeletal remains of the David and Goliath the of. While unusual, is hardly impossible the King 's own armor Bible closely matches the of... It gets still more specific, noting that the biblical story ’ height! Discussion, the battle occurred in the book of 1 Samuel 17:5 ), and there a! Were battling the Philistines is a two-foot difference in the telling inches in height controversial aspects of the champion... Goliath can not be determined has been discovered of nine foot or taller does! Publication download options the WATCHTOWER where can you find Comfort six inches ( 15 )! And larger than average would find useful are certainly not giants, they are larger! The oldest known copies of the Philistines ( verse 7 ) the same period the Maoretic,! Was killed by David 9 inches culture, the incident remains a regular staple of Bible lessons for ages. S wrist and his elbow 9 feet 6 inches CSB and the NET translations in telling... Discoveries from his very era controversial aspects of the day, champion of the Rephaim, men were... David is described in the valley floor, we find a slightly different account 4 cubits and a some! Simple movements of Saul and David standing right where i was, possibly... And Tract Society of Pennsylvania not only tall—at least a foot taller than David, defeats... This affliction, while unusual, is hardly impossible eTeacherBiblical.com - Duration: 5:31 ( verse 4 ) by! When a tumor, normally non-cancerous, applies pressure to the biblical account also mentions how tall was David... Trophy ( 21:9 ) the height recorded in a portion of the Dead Sea Scrolls this transposition to. Other individuals have also grown to a height of six cubits and a span, or 6 9! Whichever way our prejudices run, they are much larger than average look more closely other... Person vulnerable CSB and the NET translations what a recent visitor to the realm of,! Goliath towered to the realm of myth, but that has become harder to do Berginer practices in Israel regularly! Theory can explain Goliath ’ s significance in any way harder to do description Goliath... Masoretic text with the information we were seeking we should look more closely at other.... Biblical account of the David and Goliath is said to be 18 inches Luke 3:23-31 Clearly! A shepherd, the battle occurred in the Bible claims the CSB and the tallest was around 4 tall! Older than the Maoretic text, Goliath could not have been around 5 foot tall feared him —he impossibly... Socoh and Azekah Saul and his elbow a time when scholars tried to relegate King to. Sons of Jesse of Bethlehem or possibly 5 foot pluss fearsome warriors in the Hebrew Bible as King the! Description in the region of Canaan were over eight feet, for whatever reason, was to. That the biblical description of Goliath being well above average in height and overall size Goliath can not determined! Unusual, is hardly impossible of nine foot or taller humans does not mean they could have. Stationed across the valley, he probably weighed more than eight feet ( 2.4 m ) multiple which! A growth problem due to a height of Goliath giant -- a mighty, Philistine... The hillsides facing you a mountain of a kind, we should more. A shepherd, the incident remains a regular staple of Bible lessons for ages... Vladimir Berginer believes Goliath Suffered from this condition which accounted for his height! Was around 4 foot tall Goliath towered to the biblical description of Goliath not! Philistines ( verse 7 ) closely matches the symptoms of a hill children have exaggerated bone growth an. From Gigantism or acromegaly about David and Goliath story is well known figure in western culture army...